I had somehow never owned a pair of Birkenstock Arizonas, and I had no idea what size I was. It took three different sizes to get it right. If you’re buying your first pair, here’s what I learned about Birkenstock sizing, and why the Soft Footbed was worth the hassle.

Birkenstock Arizona Sizing: What I Learned
Birkenstock sizing was much harder to figure out than I expected. I even went to the Birkenstock store in Venice to get fitted, and the size they recommended ended up being too small. At one point I had all three pairs in my house at once, and the stack of boxes was honestly overwhelming.
I am a typical size 8, but my feet are on the wider side. So I first tried a 39 (which is a women’s 8-8.5) wide, but they were much too wide and slid off my feet. I then sized down one, to a 38 wide, on the advice of the Birkenstock store employee, but then the shoe was too short on me and my toes were right on the edge. Finally, I tried the 39 narrow and, to my surprise, it was a perfect fit. The soft footbed definitely molds over time to your foot too. I would say that Birkenstocks in general seem to run on the wider side so you may fit a narrow even if you typically struggle with shoes being too narrow.
Tips for Getting Your Birkenstock Size Right
- Order from a retailer with easy returns, since you may need to try more than one size.
- Don’t rely on one fitting alone. Wear them around the house before committing.
- Decide on regular or narrow width before you start swapping sizes.
Why I Chose the Soft Footbed
The Soft Footbed is very comfortable right out of the box. I also love how easy they are to slip on without worrying about laces or socks (toddler core, but make it chic).
The Stone Coin Suede Color
I went with the Arizona Soft Footbed in Stone Coin suede. I love the fuzzy look of the suede and the neutral gray color, and I haven’t seen this pair everywhere, so it feels a little different.
Any Downsides?
Only that open sandals mean you have to keep up with your pedicure. Mine have looked a little grotty more than once.
Are Birkenstock Arizonas Worth It?
Yes. Once I found the right size, they became an easy everyday favorite. I’ve now owned them for two and a half years, with fairly regular wear, and they still look great. I don’t think I would need to replace them for several more years at this rate. The gray suede in particular hides stains well, although they do have some mudstains from a damp music festival I went to! I’m still figuring out how to clean that off, but it’s not super noticeable so I don’t mind too much.
Stories from my LA life. Golden hour drives, good food, cozy corners at home, and trips near and far.
Leave a Reply